Our first meeting

Meeting the First.

Book Club the First – BOOKELF – 01-11-2009
Agreed on: The Historian by Elizabeth Kostova (AvidReader)
Discussed: Memoirs of a Geisha by Arthur Golden

Three of us.
One spicy seed cake.
A ton of coffee.
And books…in bags, on tables, in laps… books piled up all around us!
It was heavenly!
We agreed that our first official book that we would read as a group was the Historian, by Elizabeth Kostova.
We set a date for our next meeting and swopped a few books, suggested a few potential future books, and ate the spicy seed cake. Three very positive responses, one person who…shockingly…doesn’t like cake! We gasped, our determined chef resolved to try again, and cakes have now become incorportaed into our book club routine.
Could this get any better?
Well, turns out that we had all read Memoirs of a Geshia by Arthur Golden, so we were actually able to rate a book, our first meeting in!
BOOKELF = 4/5 stars
BOOKN00B = 4/5 stars
AVIDREADER = 3/5 stars
  • We agreed that the female characters were beautifully realised, and the setting and ‘world’ created seemed realistic and poetic simultaneously.
  • However, the male characters were much more one dimensional, and seems to serve purely to develop the plot further.
  • After all the agonies suffered by our heroine, was the happy ending feasible? While it certainly served to tie up the story neatly, and provide some much needed stability for the primary characters, it seemed to be hastily drawn together. There were other incidentals – the prince charming being many years older, and she being satisfied with her status as a mistress.
  • Nonetheless, a very enjoyable read, and a wonderful introduction to an otherwise unknown culture and time.
  • And we *ALL* preferred the book to the film. Like soooo much!

Write Up’s


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s